The Haunted Potluck: Spirits, Snacks, and Surprises

Featuring Storybag
Situational Comedy, Supernatural Horror
story-bag.jpg

Zoe had always been the kind of person who got a little too enthusiastic about community events. So when the annual neighborhood potluck was announced, she declared it would be the best one yet. She envisioned twinkling fairy lights, laughter echoing through the air, and mouthwatering dishes filling the tables.

But having a penchant for extravagance didn’t always work in Zoe’s favor. Last year’s event had resulted in an unfortunate incident with a giant inflatable turkey and a malfunctioning air pump that nearly caused a small explosion. But Zoe was undeterred. This year, she promised herself, it would be different.

She enlisted her neighbor, Tim, a somewhat skeptical but witty fellow who preferred the comfort of his couch over communal gatherings. "Come on, Tim! It'll be fun! Plus, I need someone to help me set up. Just think of the food!"

Tim raised an eyebrow. "Food? You mean the half-burned lasagna you made last week?"

With a huff of indignation, Zoe shot back, "That was a one-time mishap! I’m a culinary wizard now!"

Despite his reluctance, Tim couldn’t resist Zoe’s zeal, so he reluctantly agreed. As the potluck date drew closer, Zoe spent every free moment preparing decor, recipes, and a playlist that would thrill even the fussiest neighbor.

On the morning of the potluck, she woke up early, her excitement palpable. Hazarding a glance outside, she was pleased to see the sun shining, promising a perfect day. Zoe grabbed her apron, ready to unleash her newfound culinary skills, when she noticed a flyer posted on the community board: “Supernatural Sightings and Haunting Adventures: A Guided Tour!”

A lightbulb went off in Zoe’s head. "Why not add a spooky twist?" She mused. "A haunted potluck!" Tim was going to love this idea. Or hate it. Both reactions were equally valuable.

On the day of the potluck, Zoe decorated her yard with cobwebs, fake gravestones, and a few strategically placed skeletons that wouldn’t scare the kids too much. She had even made ghost-shaped cookies, complete with tiny chocolate chips for eyes. Tim, on the other hand, was tasked with bringing his famous baked beans, which he claimed were “supernatural” for how often they made people run to the loo.

As guests began to trickle in, Zoe felt a mix of pride and dread. What if they all thought her idea was silly? But as her neighbors expressed delight at her decorations, her spirits soared. Tim rolled his eyes as he set down his beans, muttering about the absurdity of it all.

"Zoe, you might have gone a little overboard with the spooky theme," he said, eyeing a particularly gaudy inflatable ghost.

"Oh, come on! It’s fun! Just wait until the best part!"

The event kicked off with an impromptu competition on who could tell the scariest ghost story while munching on her snacks. Zoe had planned everything, from the stories to the prizes—ghost-shaped keychains she’d bought online.

As the sun dipped lower, casting an orange glow through the trees, Zoe called for everyone to gather around for the storytelling contest. The neighborhood kids clambered onto picnic blankets, eyes wide with anticipation.

Tim began, recounting an old tale about a ghost haunting the abandoned house at the end of the street. His storytelling skills, peppered with humor, had everyone in stitches rather than fright. Zoe chimed in with her own creepy yarn about a witch who misplaced her cauldron, only to find it boiling in someone’s backyard, resulting in a potato salad that turned everyone into frogs.

Just as the laughter reached its peak, a low rumble echoed from the woods. The adults exchanged glances while the kids squealed in delight, believing it to be part of the festivities. Zoe, eager to keep the fun going, laughed it off too. But Tim hesitated, frowning at the now-darkening sky.

"I think we should wrap it up, Zoe. That sounds like more than thunder."

Ignoring him, Zoe announced the next event: a ghost hunt! She had earlier hidden various inflatable ghosts around the yard. The kids jumped at the challenge, racing to find them. Zoe handed out flashlights, winking conspiratorially at the parents.

As the hunt commenced, Zoe felt a strange chill in the air, but she shrugged it off, blending it with the excitement of the evening. But as the last ghost was found, a sudden gust of wind swept through the yard, throwing napkins and plates into disarray. Tim looked alarmed now, clutching his beans protectively.

"Do you feel that?" he whispered. Zoe waved it away, attributing it to seasonal breeze.

However, as the evening wore on, strange things began happening. The lights flickered, and the laugh of a child echoed eerily from the hollow of a nearby tree. Zoe dismissed it all as part of the theme. After all, a haunted potluck should have some haunted happenings, right?

But then, the food started going astray. First, the ghost cookies began to vanish. Zoe was pretty sure she had seen her neighbor Carol grab a few, but then they were gone from the table altogether. Then, Tim’s infamous baked beans mysteriously tipped over without anyone near. The adults gasped, but the kids only cheered as beans splattered on the ground.

"Zoe, this is getting weird!" Tim exclaimed, trying to scoop the beans back into the bowl.

"Don't be such a spoilsport! Just enjoy the chaos—it's all part of the fun!"

As if on cue, the inflatable ghost decorations began to float eerily into the air. Startled, the guests began to back away. Laughter morphed into nervous giggles, and Zoe swallowed hard.

"Maybe we should call it a night?" Tim suggested, finally looking somewhat serious.

Suddenly, the low rumble returned, accompanied by a flickering of shadows that danced along the trees, leaving an unsettling silence in its wake.

The kids, however, were in a frenzy, convinced the excitement was all part of Zoe’s master plan. "More scary stories!" they squealed, oblivious to the tension.

Zoe, sensing she might have pushed too far, glanced at Tim, who was now visibly sweating as he scanned the surroundings.

“Okay, everyone!” Zoe announced, attempting to sound upbeat. “How about we wrap up with a toast? To our spooky potluck!”

As everyone raised their cups, shadows flickered again, and a loud crack echoed from the woods. A nearby tree branch broke off, crashing down near the food table, sending everyone screeching and scrambling.

Tim let out an exaggerated yell, clutching his heart. “That’s it! I’m out before the ghosts take me!”

Before anyone could protest, he bolted for the exit, with Zoe chasing after him. "Wait! You can’t leave! It’s just…just spooky!"

As the rest of the party fell into chaos, Zoe couldn’t help but laugh. Maybe the potluck had gone a little awry, but it would definitely be a night to remember.

With a loud cheer from the remaining kids, Zoe glanced back at the swirling shadows and the laughing neighbors, realizing that sometimes, a little chaos was exactly what made an event memorable. As she joined Tim in the car, pulling away from the chaotic scene, Zoe couldn’t help but chuckle.

"Next year, we’re just doing lasagna." Tim sighed, half-relieved, half-amused.

Zoe grinned. "But think of all the spooky food possibilities!"

And as they drove off, the ghosts of the evening lingered, an uninvited yet welcomed part of their eclectic neighborhood life.

Story Written By
Thadwin
Thadwin

Do you want to read more stories about Storybag? You are in luck because there are 1744 stories!